gynads wrote:Scirocco 2.0 Tsi GT (possibly one of niche`s RC 280`s)
Mk 6 Golf GTi 2.0
Audi S3
2nd hand BMW 335i/335id
Hi gynads, and welcome. Thats a nice list you have there, IMHO the Scirocco is a much better looking car than the Mk 6 golf (I actually think the Mk 5 looks better than the Mk 6!) The 335D beemer and the Audi S3 are both great motors, so you have a FWD (Scirocco) RWD (beemer) and 4WD (audi). Personally I would rank the Scirocco and the audi as joint first with the beemer slightly behind. Dont get me wrong, the beemer is a great car, but I believe overpriced for what you get, I prefer the 2.0tsi engine to the beemer lump (having owned both) and I feel the audi and the Scirocco provide a better all round driving experience (and nothing to do with petrol v diesel before Le_Sav or rocket says anything!!)
So that leaves the Scirocco and the audi, hmm, now thats a hard one. I think the Scirocco looks MUCH better and is obviously a newer car however the audi is 4WD and has 268bhp against the rocs 197bhp standard.
On balance though, I would get the Scirocco, remap it, stick an exhaust and induction kit on and bobs your uncle!! (Or wait for the R20 and get the best of both worlds!!)
As for PCP I cant help you, although I would reckon if you are looking at the Audi v Scirocco, as the Scirocco is cheaper new the PCP cost is likely to be less.